Our Pet’s Health is community-supported. When you buy through links on my site, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you (learn more).
Advances in veterinary medicine have provided us with an incredible array of options for treating our pets, from groundbreaking surgical procedures to targeted medications.
And these innovations have undoubtedly saved countless animal lives, offering hope to pet parents dealing with illnesses and injuries that were once considered untreatable.
But as we continue to develop more complex and costly treatments, we often find ourselves facing diminishing returns. The improvements these advanced interventions bring can sometimes be minor, especially when weighed against their financial and emotional costs.
Therefore, it's crucial for pet parents to navigate this landscape with a clear understanding of what truly benefits their furry family members.
In this episode of the Call the Vet Show, Dr. Alex Avery delves into the concept of diminishing returns in pet healthcare, discussing practical examples and offering guidance on how to make informed decisions for your pet's well-being.
“Just because we can do something, the end result of that intervention, the end result of that treatment may not really make a huge amount of difference to your individual pet.”
Understanding Diminishing Returns in Veterinary Care
To begin, let's define what I mean by "diminishing returns" in the context of veterinary care.
Essentially, this is where additional input—whether it's financial, technological, or procedural—leads to progressively smaller increases in the output, which, in our case, means the improvement in the health and quality of life of our pets.
This phenomenon isn't unique to veterinary care; it’s apparent in human healthcare as well.
In simpler terms, it takes more complex and costly interventions to achieve smaller and sometimes more marginal benefits for our pets.
And as the bar for medical innovation rises, so does the associated cost, often making it harder for pet parents to afford these advanced treatments.
The Evolution of Pet Healthcare: From Simple Fixes to Advanced Interventions
Reflecting on how pet healthcare has evolved, it’s apparent that we’ve come a long way from the days of simpler, low-cost treatments. Take antibiotics, for example. When they were first introduced, they revolutionized our ability to treat infections. Similarly, steroids were once frequently used to manage itching in dogs, despite their side effects.
Today, we have drugs like Apoquel and Cytopoint, which, while more targeted and safer, come at a significantly higher cost.
Consider cruciate ligament disease, a common knee injury in dogs. Years ago, we performed relatively simple surgeries like the lateral suture technique. While effective, this technique has been largely replaced by more complex procedures like the TPLO (Tibial Plateau Leveling Osteotomy), which involves cutting and rotating the bone to alter knee joint angles.
Although TPLO may provide a better outcome, the cost is substantially higher due to the specialized training and equipment required.
Another area exhibiting diminishing returns is cancer treatment. Oncology has made tremendous strides, offering more treatment options than ever before.
However, the cost and complexity of these treatments have increased exponentially, often (but not always) for relatively small gains in life expectancy.
The Financial Realities of Advanced Veterinary Care
The rising cost of advanced veterinary care is a significant concern. As we develop more sophisticated drugs, diagnostic tools, and surgical techniques, the financial burden on pet parents continues to grow. This is important to consider when deciding on the best course of action for your pet.
For instance, while advanced surgeries like the TPLO might offer better outcomes, they are not always accessible or affordable. Similarly, cutting-edge cancer treatments involving multiple drugs, hospitalizations, and close monitoring can be prohibitively expensive for many families.
The small gains in quality of life or life expectancy may not justify the high costs in every case, especially if the treatment does not significantly impact your pet's overall prognosis.
The Role of Pet Parents: Making Informed Decisions
When it comes to your pet's health, it's essential to weigh the costs and benefits of different treatment options. Here are a few questions to consider:
What is the cost of the intervention?
Understanding the financial implications is crucial.
What benefit will it provide?
Consider whether the treatment will cure the condition, significantly improve quality of life, or merely extend it by a short period. What are the potential diseases a test is hoping to uncover? If they are not treatable (or for whatever reason you would not proceed with the treatments that are available) then is it worth doing the test in the first place?
What are the alternatives?
Sometimes, simpler, less costly treatments can be almost as effective in maintaining or improving your pet’s quality of life.
The Ethical Perspective: Balancing Care and Cost
While it's fantastic to have various advanced treatments available, we must be cautious not to let the pursuit of gold-standard care drive up the costs of basic treatments.
For instance, over-reliance on specialist procedures can make general practice treatments less accessible.
Additionally, the push for routine tests and monitoring might deter pet parents from seeking necessary care due to cost concerns.
Fear and Defensive Medicine: The Hidden Influences
Another factor influencing these rising costs is the fear factor driving veterinarians to practice defensive medicine.
Fearing litigation, complaints, and online reviews, many vets recommend extensive tests and advanced treatments to cover all bases.
While this is generally done with the best intentions (and not greed), it can inadvertently increase the financial burden on pet parents.
The Art of Veterinary Medicine: Nurturing Relationships
At the heart of effective veterinary care is the relationship between the vet and the pet parent.
Open, honest communication about treatment options, costs, and potential outcomes is vital.
Understanding your financial situation, as well as goals and expectations for your pet, allows veterinarians to tailor their recommendations, balancing the best possible care with affordability.
Conclusion: A Call for Balance
In conclusion, while advanced veterinary care offers incredible opportunities to improve pet health, it's essential to recognize the concept of diminishing returns.
Not every innovation will significantly benefit every pet, and the financial costs can be substantial.
As pet parents and veterinarians, we must navigate these complexities together, making informed decisions that prioritize the well-being of our pets without imposing undue financial strain.
Subscribe to the Call The Vet Show to ensure that you never miss a future episode!